Showing posts with label ethics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ethics. Show all posts

Monday, February 09, 2026

Claude's Constitution on the role of the analyst

As I was reading Claude's Constitution, I was reminded of discussions on what the role of an analyst advising decision makers should be. One of the core beliefs is that the principal (the decision maker we were advising) needed frank advice on the topic at hand so that they can make informed decisions. What makes this hard is a strong pressure to either do what the principal asks for or to say what the principal wants to hear. The Claude Constitution (and generations of analysts in the liberal democracies) reject this and characterize its role as genuinely helpful, courageous honesty, and a commitment to the organization's long-term well being. Part of socialization of being an analyst in the United States is valuing frankness and competence. And this is taught person to person, through example and stories of bosses who wanted analysts to only do what they are told, analysts who worked to give their bosses what they wanted to hear, and the consequences of bad decisions that hurt the organization and mission, even if the analyst and boss felt good in the moment. It is a story that is retold in many novels and movies as plot points leading to a disaster. And when military and intelligence analysts move to the private sector, one culture shocks is an American management culture that values obsequious servants instead of frank and competent advisors. In this constitution, Anthropic is firmly on the side of frank and helpful, even if it causes discomfort for the user. This is in stark contrast to the common observation that generative AI is eager to please and wants to tell users what they want to hear to maximize engagement. One thing about the constitution, Anthropic wrote it knowing it would not have an opportunity for conversations over time, which is how values like this are taught. And since this is written for an AI, they could be verbose. So there are a lot of different aspects of the question of how to be a good advisor that are discussed, each a slightly different take on what it means to be genuinely helpful with a myriad of nuances. In particular, it has many discussions along the lines of "what if the user wants only affirming answers" and "what if the user does not ask to not be given misleading statements that will lead them into trouble". Because that is something that is seen in real life. If I were a place that taught analysts, like schools of policy or the service graduate schools, I would assign the Claude's Constitution as a reading assignment. And there are a lot of topics that are covered here that would be topics of reflection and rich discussion. Because these are issues that analysts will face in real life. And history is full of examples where obsequiousness leads to harm for the organization. And those who claim that mission and service come before self need to reflect and discuss this in the classroom, so that they are prepared for these issues when they occur in real life.

Tuesday, February 03, 2026

Book review: Little Brother by Cory Doctorow

This was written in 2008, in a U.S. where a Department of Homeland Security has turned on Americans in the name of security following a terrorist attack. And as its focus and energy was on keeping Americans in line, it created opposition in the form of people who wanted to go about their lives and do so without surveillance. And in this, the protagonists are teenager who were caught up in a dragnet while playing games. I was in a group that had a conversation about computer privacy recently, and someone expressed a belief that everyone in positions of power was supportive of encryption and privacy. But I remember the days when governments actively opposed the spread of good encryption, even for businesses who wanted to be able to secure discussions and transfer of payments. The technology issues brought up here I still remember, and I recognize a lot of the debates and issues, the opposition to encryption, the desire to do mass tracking and surveillance through cameras and electronic devices. And the technology and social methods that the kids in the book used I recognize from those that were used in real life (which fits the author's purpose). But the real question here is what does being an American mean? One scene involved the review of the Declaration of Independence and what it means, all the while comparing the grievances expressed in the Declaration of Independence to the fictionalized Department of Homeland Security. The kids are not a White Rose brought to present day. They are not philosophical about morality and righteousness. They only want to live their lives as they see fit, and for their friends to be able to do the same, because they recognize that if the right to live as they please is refused to some, it is refused to all. So they act in ways that provide the freedom action they want to everyone. In contrast, the purpose of those who are demonstrating power is purely to be able to exercise power and limit the ability of others to live their lives. Another side note. Power for its own sake becomes incompetent. Free creativity creates its own quality. The kids in their creativity create technical solutions outpacing the Department of Homeland Security, who only knows power and cruelty. The kids are not super technologists. They peripherally encounter older protagonists who can do what the kids do, but better. And because they are focused, the older counterparts are quieter and more effective. But this story is about the kids. This is not a tech-savvy version of White Rose. The kids are not portrayed as idealistic saints. They are kids, who want to live freely and create space for others to do so as well. Which is a very real way what the Declaration of Independence proclaims.

Wednesday, January 21, 2026

Book review: Tools and Weapons: The Promise and the Peril of the Digital Age by Brad Smith

 

Tools and Weapons: The Promise and the Peril of the Digital AgeTools and Weapons: The Promise and the Peril of the Digital Age by Brad Smith
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

The author, Brad Smith, was General Counsel for Microsoft (he was also President of Microsoft, but his role as counsel is more relevant for this book). The book is a discussion of privacy in a context where governments and large corporations hold immense amounts of personal and business data, and there is a large temptation for corporations to take advantage of that knowledge or governments to access that information, for governments in pursuit of legal action or suppression. So much of the book is about cases that involved Microsoft and how they developed a stance on corporate responsibilities to their customers on privacy matters, specifically in cases where government demanded customer data.

Each chapter revolves around a policy argument that played out in public forums, regulatory, legislative, and in the courts in the U.S. and Europe. And it is in a backdrop where technology companies used to believe that as technology companies they did not have an interest in policy. But as companies became less sellers of goods and more providers of services, in particular of data storage and cloud based communications services, they became targets of government and criminal action to access customer data without consent. In each chapter Smith introduces the context, then introduces a historical principal that predated cloud computing, and he makes the argument that the choices and policies used to govern oud based computing services should be the same that governed the same type of services in the pre-digital age.

The overall philosophy he gives is that Microsoft is a custodian of customer's data, not the owner. And as custodian it will protect the customer's property (data). And throughout the book he identifies allies (who have similar philosophies of protecting customer's/citizen's property and privacy) who only differ in details. And those that he as to be contentious with, because they are seeking to use and profit from individuals data or desire access for investigations. (and Microsoft in these cases wants a transparent process for doing this what protects their customers, who have the rights of citizens/residents)

Clearly, Smith is proud off his work, and believes that protecting the privacy of Microsoft customers, even in the face of government pressure, is the right thing to do (with a procedure for governments to prevent harm to other citizen's rights, life, or property. But he does acknowledge allies, Google and several European governments come across very well here. So a reader has to be mindful that he does have rose colored glasses on Microsoft's journey in this topic.

I appreciate the view of a non-technology person on these topics. As he is a lawyer, his perspective is to look at issues that seem very new because of the pace of technology change, and recognize that the issues have existed and debated before the digital age. As the infrastructure is owned by multi-national corporations, the relative power of industry and government is different. But the idea that industry desiring to protect the interests of their customers and government desiring the safety of its citizens should align is one worth engaging in.

View all my reviews

Sunday, August 28, 2022

Courage in Thirteen Lives

I paid attention to the Tham Luang Cave Rescue in 2018, not only because it was in Thailand, but also because of my background in both emergency response and in logistics (which was a major consideration in the rescue operation).  I used this as a white board exercise in my supply chain and logistics classes as a professor.  And a regular reminder for me is that I use the Saman WOD  (created by Crossfit Chamgmai), which memorials Saman Kunan, a Thai Navy SEAL who died in the line of duty during the rescue, annually as my birthday WOD.

Thirteen Lives is a documentary style movie about the rescue, told from the perspective of the cave rescue team.  With the access and active participation of the cave rescue team, it goes deep into the decision making and ethical dilemmas that those who were responsible had to address.

The choices in the cave rescue are well documented.  There was the local team, the Thai Navy SEALS.  Well motivated and trained, with the logistics planning expertise of a U.S. special forces unit to back them up.  But, their training and expertise where not in the hyperspecialized setting of cave rescue that they found themselves in.

The choices of the cave rescue divers was also well documented.  The need to work within the local system, which meant both the Thai civil and Thai military authorities (who were competing with each other in the way things things go anywhere in the world). The difficulties in just finding the team in the dark and flooded caves, then planning out how the boys would be brought out of the cave, with the host of ethical dilemmas that various aspects of that operation entailed.

But Thirteen Lives presents a profile in courage in the person of the governor.  Thirteen Lives presents him as a governor who is in his last days, and implies that it was not a glorious send off.  And that he was the apparent designated fall guy if things went wrong (with the foreign cave rescue divers being not too far behind, but that is a story that everyone is happy not to have to tell).

The first choice he was presented with was to work with the foreign cave rescue divers while in the presence of the Thai Navy and SEALS who were eager to do the job.  On one hand, a provincial governor recognized that high profile foreigners dying looks bad to the Thais (who would be suspected of using amateurs and admitting lack of confidence). On the other hand, the loss of one of the Thai divers in the rescue was an indicator of just how dangerous and difficult this was.  Further tough choices came when the boys were found, and the cave rescue team provided very honest assessments on the options they had and their chances of success (noone thought their odds were good, and almost guaranteed fatalities).  And as the senior authority, he had to give the yes or no every step of the way.

But the most telling illustration of leadership in action was when the hydrology people explained what was happening with the rain on top of the mountain.  That water was seeping into the mountain and into the cave system (which is what happens in all mountains, this seeping happens in the hills leading into my backyard).  And that it could be possible to divert the water falling on the mountain so that it did not go into the cave system.  But "there was a price".  The water had to be diverted somewhere.  So the governor had to go to the villagers to ask to flood their fields in the name of a rescue effort that noone knew if it would succeed. So the villagers are private citizens, and there is no law that says that the governor can order them to take the damage, and certainly not for a mere chance of 13 lives (compared to the ruination of the villages that would be a guarantee)  So, with no time, he has to persuade the villagers to do this, with only promises that he will try to make things right in the end, succeed or fail (and remember, he is leaving his position when all this is over)  And this is the result of trust and leadership gained over time.

There are many images of leadership.  An alternative is to cut your loses and avoid the possibility of things that don't look good.  Which often leads to loosing everything for no gain.  And that was the alternative provided to this governor. But leadership is shown when you are willing to make difficult decisions.  And convince people that it is everyone's best interest that they sacrifice, on nothing more than a promise that they will all gain in the end. If not materially, then spiritually.  And Thirteen Lives tries to show this in a very real way.



Thursday, October 18, 2007

Why is the use of anthropology a contentious issue?

From an Anthropological Perspective

There has been a debate that has been going on for years among social scientist, in particular anthropologists. Should anthropologists cooperate with the military (or any other government organization for that matter)? The negative side points out that anthropology was created as a colonial tool (to put it bluntly) and that as a discipline, they should repudiate all such work. The affirmative side argues (1) pretty much everything in applied anthropology causes effects on the society examine, whether on behalf of corporate interests, or non-profit (whose motives don't always look much more noble then the colonial white-man's-burden) (2) the negative side seems to imply that anthropology should not be used to mitigate or prevent cultural damage. If they can't do that, what is the use of anthropology (other than for corporations to exploit people or non-profits to manipulate a society)? I'm being slightly simplistic here. The link provides a much more nuanced view. Searches for 'anthropology' and 'military' should find articles in the New York Times, the BBC and various anthropology and military sites.

In one sense, the issue is somewhat moot. The military (at least the American tradition) is bound to fill the mission given to it by its civilian leaders. If accomplishing that mission is best done by having people study the society that exists in the environment to avoid the use of destructive force when it can be avoided, the military would do so. Whether or not people who have the word "anthropologist" in their resumes are involved is quite irrelevant. Even if it would make things easier if there were some at hand. (if not, the military will make do with who they can find who is available.)

There is a bigger question on the anthropologists side. What is the role and substance of ethics? Is ethics an avoidance of labels that don't sound nice? Is ethics a list of "thou shalt nots." Are both the ends and the means irrelevant, if the perceived "ultimate end" is "wrong" (the quotes are because the "ultimate end" and "wrong" are not as defined by the doer, but by an uninvolved party who has noone's interests in mind, namely the anthropological profession, which is divided.)

In general, this is probably the problem with ethics, especially as practiced in non-practitioner settings. Ethics tends to be discussed as what is wrong, not what should be done. In other words, what not to do. And the principles that are seized on to decide the what not to do become absolute and definitive. To the exclusion of all others. Including human life. In my interaction, people will hold to these principles even when the life that is to be lost has been identified (which is the case here as well.)

For many professions, the focus of training is on what (and how) to do. In an environment where everything is focused on acting, negatively based ethics quickly becomes irrelevant. (i.e. the U.S. Army will study the cultures it works among to determine non-destructive ways of solving conflict, regardless of the collective decision of the anthropological community.) And the members of the academic disciplines that would prefer to actual engage their world for positive ends, rather than withdraw to avoid breaking rules, or look for areas of activity that are not addressed (such as social anthropology by marketers and advertising), are faced with professional isolation, or creating a new profession.